And then there were 12! Tonight we
get to see for the first time this season, the top 6 guys and the top 6 girls
on the same stage! This being the even larger stage. I’m really excited about
it! As I started last week, I will be rating the idols on how I think they did
(as in rank wise) I will not however be posting their “rank” from last week
because that was out of 8, not 12. Here we go!
I have decided that this season I
will watch the show and judge without the imput of the judges. I mute them
while I type my results. Then I replayed the results during breaks and said who
I agreed with. Honestly!! These performances are in order so if you are still
up until 12:00 PM EST tonight, you can still call in! Remember the number is
1-866-IDOLS(43657)-(their two digits eg. 01 or 12) OR if you have a AT&T
Wireless phone, you can text the word VOTE to 57(their two digits). ((OK now I
really feel like Ryan))
01. Syesha Mercado sang Got
To Get You Into My Life by The Beatles.
How I think they did: There were some pitch problems at the beginning… but it
ended OK.
I agree with Randy on replay.
My Order (This week: 7) (Last week:
-)
02. Chikezie Eze sang She’s
a Woman by The Beatles.
How I think they did: That was completely AMAZING! That was the best risk of
the night so far. He will definitely make it another week!
I agree with on Simon replay.
My Order (This week: 5) (Last week:
-)
03. Ramile Malubay sang In
My Life by The Beatles.
How I think they did: First off, the arms swaying thing from the audience was
LAME. The performance was good but just didn’t rock my world. The whole thing
was too safe for her.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 10) (Last week:
-)
04. Jason Castro sang If I
Fell by The Beatles.
How I think they did: That was a great performance. But it ended up kinda
boring. He could have done it better.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 8) (Last week:
-)
05. Carly Smithson sang Come
Together by The Beatles.
How I think they did: Watching that, I didn’t hear a bit out of tune! It was brilliant!
Definitely going to go far because of that performance.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 2) (Last week:
-)
06. David Cook sang Eleanor
Rigby by The Beatles.
How I think they did: AMAZING. Started a bit iffy but then the chorus hit it
ROCKED! He will go far.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 3) (Last week:
-)
07. Brooke White sang Let
it Be by The Beatles.
How I think they did: That was awesome. Truly did it for me. One of my favorite
Beatles songs. She has the talent to go very far.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 4) (Last week:
-)
08. David Hernandez sang I
Saw Her Standing There by The Beatles.
How I think they did: It had a lot of pitch problems. He overdid the whole
thing. I’ll be surprised if he makes it to next week.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 11) (Last week:
-)
09. Amanda Overmyer sang You
Can’t Do That by The Beatles.
How I think they did: I didn’t think it was as good as last week. But it was
really well done.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 6) (Last week:
-)
10. Michael Johns sang Across
the Universe by The Beatles.
How I think they did: It didn’t work for me. I got bored watching and did
something else. Its time to let it go and sing better! That’s that.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 9) (Last week:
-)
11. Kristy Lee Cook sang 8
Days a Week by The Beatles.
How I think they did: I don’t know… I’m half and half about it (like Randy)
I agree with on replay.
My Order (This week: 12) (Last week:
-)
12. David Archuleta sang We
Can Work It Out by The Beatles.
How I think they did: It wasn’t his best. But he did the best he could. Still
getting top marks from me because he will get top votes. No doubt! I also
believe he forgot the words at one point.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 1) (Last week:
-)
Overall, everyone did a fantastic job tonight! I ABSOLUTLY
LOVED the new stage! It’s such a big difference from years prior. My bottom
three means that one of them should be going home this week. So, Ramiel, David
H, and Kristy Lee Cook have the best chance at going home. Send in those votes
everyone!!