'Idol' and '5th grader'
I tried a different format last week for Idol and it seemed
to work well, so this week, I will use the same format, unless someone else has
an idea. Tonight is the top 10 guys! Hopefully they are better than last week.
I have decided that this season I will watch the show and
judge without the imput of the judges. I mute them while I type my results.
Then I replayed the results during breaks and said who I agreed with.
Honestly!! These performances are in order so if you are still up until 12:00
PM EST tonight, you can still call in! Remember the number is
1-866-IDOLS(43657)-(their two digits eg. 01 or 12) OR if you have a Cingular
Wireless phone, you can text the word VOTE to 57(their two digits). ((OK now I
really feel like Ryan))
01. Philip Joel "Phil" Stacey sang Missing You by John Waite.
How I think
they did: he started way off pitch. He did pick a pretty good song for who he
dedicated it to. At parts he looked like Chris Daughtry. Just didn’t sound like
him.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 5) (Last week: 3)
02. Jared Cotter sang Lets Get It On by Marvin Gaye.
How I think
they did: He sang better than he did last week. It was pitchy at times. But he
did a very good job.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 8) (Last week: 8)
03. Antonio Javier "A.J." Tabaldo sang Feeling Good by Nina Simone.
How I think
they did: He is feelin good after that one! That was awesome!!
I agree with Randy on replay.
My Order (This week: 6) (Last week: 4)
04. Sanjaya Malakar sang Steppin’ Out With My Baby by Tony Bennett.
How I think
they did: I thought it was really bad actually. His song was too easy.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 9) (Last week: 7)
05. Chris Sligh sang Trouble by Ray LaMontagne.
How I think
they did: It was a very good song! He did get ahead of the music at times but
it was very good.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 3) (Last week: 2)
06. Nicholas Pedro sang Fever by Peggy Lee.
How I think
they did: It was better than last week. But I think he could do better. It was
pitchy…
I agree with Randy on replay.
My Order (This week: 7) (Last week: 6)
07. Blake Lewis sang Virtual Insanity by Jamiroquai.
How I think
they did: It started off like last week, but I thought it was weak. He missed
the high note. The beat boxing was nice though. I still think he is the best
guy singing.
I agree with Randy, Simon on
replay.
My Order (This week: 1) (Last week: 1)
08. Brandon Rogers sang Time After Time by Cyndi Lauper.
How I think
they did: The song was dedicated to the right person. It just wasn’t … good. It
did not wow me.
I agree with Simon on replay.
My Order (This week: 10) (Last week: 11)
09. Chris Richardson sang Geek in the Pink by Jason Mraz.
How I think
they did: I like this song from Mraz, This rendition is pretty good actually.
He needs new moves.
I agree with All three on replay.
My Order (This week: 4) (Last week: 5)
10. Jason “Sundance”
Head sang Mustang Sally by Wilson Pickett.
How I think
they did: WOW, that was awesome!!! He is back!
I agree with Randy on replay.
My Order (This week: 2) (Last week: 9)
The guys did well tonight, but they could still do better. After
the show was “Are you Smarter than a 5th Grader” which was awesome!
I knew all the answers except one. Tomorrow, more Idol and 5th Grader.