A Counting School - Hardcore Chartered Accountancy

since 1494

What will SICKO's immediate effects be on health care in other countries?

Studying while hospitalized - in Canada

Michael Moore's new movie Sicko deals with the complete disaster known as the USA's health care

Giving your money to companies with a vested interest in keeping it and then hoping they'll pay you back when you need it to pay for a condition that they reserve the right to diagnose is, at best, an exercise in optimism - that is, being so optimistic that you believe that corporations will do what's Right rather than what's Super Profitable.

With that brief summary of Moore's entire opus in mind - it's a Really Good Film - I wondered what the immediate effect would be. After all, the movie's a call to arms, to go ahead and do something to make things better for the United States.

Some of the film's most powerful scenes came from his trips abroad. He crossed the river to see how we do things in Canada, jumped the pond to check out England and France, and paid a very moving visit to Cuba.

And that's what it's going to come to, it seems.

Medical tourism.

Go and Google it. 21 million hits. A million if you put the term in quotation marks. That's still huge.

And who cares about digging deep - the proof of how big this is - not going to be, is - comes from the fact that you see tons of Google ads. Three pages of ads, actually, if you hit the "more ads" button.

Aside: talk about genius marketing - a "more ads" button. Instead of shoving commercial messages down users' throats, give them the option of grabbing a handful whenever they feel like it.

It's not a new practice. Citizens of countries like Canada have considered med-tourism to skip line-ups that can occur in our public system.

The interesting twist, of course, is that Americans would be doing it to save money instead of time. Medical tourism is big already. Time covered it last year. With the sensational media attention a movie like Moore's will generate, is it set to explode?

And is health care like other commodities or services, where increased demand causes prices to rise? Is this phenomenon going to screw over other countries? I mean, wouldn't that be a clever tactic: instead of blockading Cuba, perhaps the US should just let all its sick citizens go and visit, overwhelming Cuba's health care system.

That's a facetious thought, of course, but the economic question remains. Will American medical tourism dollars end up subsidizing public systems, or will they instead leech resources away from them?

As the price of hotels and airfare continues to be exceeded by the horrendous cost of treatment in the States this'll continue to be an interesting phenomenon to watch.

Comments

Bahnsen8 said:

This issue is close to my heart. I am a physician and a Christian who believes the Bible has the answer to life's questions if we will just listen. Yes, even economic questions and how they overlap with health care and ecclesiology and political philosophy are all addressed in the Bible, if we will just look.

I totally agree that it is ludicrous to give money to a company as "insurance" against a health crisis, especially when the up-front, stated goal of these corporations is to make money. So, I do not really fault the insurance companies that much. I think the American consumer has been utterly duped and completely uncreative and lazy in its search for any alternatives. No matter your political, religious or social leanings, everyone agrees this current system is really bad for sick people.

Having said that, and guessing at Moore's political philosophy, and having not seen the SICKO film, I guess that his suggested solution probably places most of the fix with the government. It's probably something like, "Let's take the money from the greedy, evil, rich businessmen and give it to the loving, good, caring government to fix the broken medical system." This is Marxist statism at its best and ANY half-decent historian should know on the front end that this is doomed to fail in the long run. Why? Because the same greed that motivated the businessmen is present in the heart of the statesmen.

Solution? Individuals should come together in large groups and pool their money into large catastrophe accounts. This would be especially easy for local church communities. Then, establish a NOT FOR PROFIT, NON-GOVERNMENT organization to administer the fund for the group, with close supervision by the fund contributors. The pay for the people administering the fund would be a FIXED pay that MUST NOT VARY based on how they manage the fund. As soon as personal profit for the fund manager enters the picture, the whole thing is DOOMED. Give them a fixed salary with good benefits, raises as appropriate for loyal and competent service.

One group doing something like this is Samaritan Ministries.

www.samaritanministries.org/index.html

Thanks for the insightful post.

# June 30, 2007 12:34 PM

Krupo said:

Thanks for the comment.

You're right in that moral goodness is trumped by profit-seeking in the case of health insurance companies in the USA.

# July 1, 2007 2:58 AM

A Counting School said:

I recently wrote about new Moore movie and the effect it would have on medical tourism. Of course, that's

# July 1, 2007 3:19 AM